Welcome to Bay Street Tavern
Located at 1384 Bay St, Staten Island, Bay Street Tavern is a vibrant local hotspot that seamlessly blends great food, live entertainment, and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests rave about the delicious dishes, with favorites like the Reuben and tasty burgers, complemented by reasonably priced drinks. The tavern's lively setting features a charming patio and frequent live music, creating an environment that invites guests to unwind and connect. Patrons appreciate the attentive service and the sense of community fostered by friendly locals. With its engaging events and mouthwatering menu, Bay Street Tavern is the perfect place to relax and enjoy a fantastic night out.
-
1384 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305, United States Hotline: +1 718-720-3254
Welcome to Bay Street Tavern, an inviting gem nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 1384 Bay St. This neighborhood tavern is not just a spot to grab a pint; it’s a vibrant hub where excellent food, good music, and a welcoming atmosphere come together to create an unforgettable experience.
As you step into Bay Street Tavern, you’re greeted by the lively hum of conversation accompanied by the sounds of local bands that regularly grace the small stage. Patrons rave about nights filled with live music, like the beloved band Mercury Rising, drawing in crowds and creating a sense of community that makes everyone feel at home.
Speaking of community, the locals are a crucial part of the Bay Street experience. Many customers, like RIV and Laura Cannon, highlight the friendly vibe and camaraderie that allows friendships to blossom amongst regulars. Whether you're visiting after a long bike ride or just looking for a chill evening spot, the warm service and lively atmosphere are sure to put a smile on your face.
The menu offers a delightful array of American bar classics. You can indulge in the much-praised Reuben from RIV's review or the superb grilled cheese paired with French onion soup hailed by Elaine Messi. Each dish comes prepared with an emphasis on flavor and quality. Many are pleased to find that dishes exceed expectations for a ‘dive bar’ (though they are far from dive-worthy), showcasing that here, delicious food and affordable prices do go hand in hand.
And let's not forget the drinks! Casual and accessible, the bar ensures everyone finds something to enjoy. Fans describe their beverages as ‘stiff’ and perfectly priced, making it easy to sip and savor the night.
With an outdoor patio that boasts games and a charming ambiance, Bay Street Tavern caters to those sunny days and evening hangouts. Enjoying a fresh pot of coffee while watching the Mets game is just one of many experiences that make this establishment a unique choice for anyone looking to unwind.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Bay Street Tavern promises not just a meal, but a memorable outing filled with laughter, delicious food, and fantastic musical entertainment. So why not pay a visit? You may just find your new favorite spot in Staten Island!
Came here to see my favorite band Mercury Rising! They were amazing as always and draw a nice sized crowd. Bar is very reasonably priced. Good service!
Man this place is awesome! Atmosphere is great food is amazing and the locals are so welcoming. Drinks and food prices are perfect. They even have an outside patio with games that are a good time. I highly recommend. It’s a place that makes you feel at home. I ordered the Reuben and it was amazing!!!!!!!!!!! Cash bar only but they have an ATM and it I’m your charges 1.75
We had such a nice time here. What a surprise that we coincidentally showed up on a Wednesday night at 9 PM right when they were having a band. The atmosphere was great. The service was fantastic and the food was delicious. We had the grilled cheese with French onion soup And it tasted so good.
Amazing people, Amazing vibe. I'd spend all my downtime here with the kick ass patrons who've become friends.
Went here after a long long bike ride with my friends. The service was amazing and everyone was so friendly. The food was delicious. Especially love the touch of pasta salad and the way it was spiced. Incredible french fries. They gave me an extra pickle for my burger. Additionally, they put on a fresh pot of coffee for us! It was nice to see the Mets game on the screen, even though they lost. I wonder what team this institution roots for.
Lively place on a Thursday!! Definitely a local spot but everyone was nice, service was good. Got mozzarella sticks, cheeseburger and blt. Food was better than expected for a dive bat, I REALLY like the burger it was cooked well and was good quality. The drink was nice and STIFF (just how I like it) Best part of the night was Elvis!!! What a nice surprise and it was fun to watch him sing and dance. Attaching a calendar as they seem to have events almost every night.
The ladies inside were so pleasant and sweet. We didn't have the food but customer service is top notch! Highly recommend and the bathrooms were very clean.
I loved the ambience, staff were very friendly and attentive. The music / chareoke very entertaining. The food was very good. The Halloween party was amazing enjoyed every minute with our friends Our friend won best costume Lady Liberty .