Bay Street Tavern Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Bay Street Tavern, a local gem situated at 1384 Bay St, Staten Island, NY. This lively spot is more than just a tavern; it’s a hub of community, music, and delicious food. The menu features classic comfort foods crafted from fresh ingredients, exemplified by the highly praised Reuben sandwich and unbeatable grilled cheese paired with French onion soup.

Beyond the enticing dishes, the atmosphere is vibrant, attracting locals and visitors alike. With a cash bar and reasonable prices, patrons enjoy everything from mozzarella sticks to hearty burgers. Diners rave about the exceptional service and welcoming vibe, making each visit feel like coming home.

• Highlights:
• Live music events that enhance the dining experience.
• An outdoor patio perfect for leisurely meals with friends.
• Games to enjoy while sipping on expertly crafted drinks.

At Bay Street Tavern, every meal comes with a side of community spirit!